indya.com
STAR Player
 
Home
 
Forums
 
Star Box Office
 
Gallery
 Events
 Dus Ya Bas
 In or Out
 Then 'n' Now
 
Quiz
 
Fan Club
 
Events
  STAR Parivaar...
 Screen Awards
 
Poll Pool
 
Videos
 
Downloads
 
Fashion
 
Kollywood
 
Timepass Zone
 
Games
 
Cricket
 
Astrology
 
Fantasy Date
 
STAR Parivaar Club
 
Mirch Masala
 
Chat
 
Chat Transcripts
 
Archives
 
RSS
 
Programme Guide
 
Feedback
 
Heroes Season 4 Contest Rules
 
Untitled

Movie Reviews Other Movies >>
Black & White
Rate Now
Indya.com rating


Cast
Anil Kapoor, Shefali Shah, Anurag Sinha, Aditi Sharma

Related Reviews
Black and White works intermittently. It is a well-meaning but flawed film. I recommend it, with reservations, for its sincerity.
Anupama Chopra
NDTV

Subhash Ghai's Black & White is an amateurish effort from a filmmaker clearly out of his depth as far as his subject matter is concerned.
Rajeev Masand
IBN Live

Any attempt to reflect the realpolitik, is entirely supportable - particularly at a juncture when entertainment is equated with trouser-dropping farce and smutty sexual innuendo.
Khalid Mohamed
Hindustan Times

The film has great performances by Anil Kapoor, Shefali Shah and Anuraag Sinha. It's an honest attempt, which would have fared better if the producers had not tried to commercialise the plot.
Preeti Arora
Buzz 18

Black & White is neither disturbingly dark nor lucidly light. It’s somewhere in between. Perhaps gracefully grey!
Gaurav Malani
Indiatimes
SynopsisGalleryDiscussions

StarBoxOffice.com Review

Acting: Debutante Anurag exhibits his good talent with his brooding, intense act playing the cold blooded terrorist. He succeeds in showcasing his anguish and the steady change in his beliefs very well. Anil Kapoor yet again proves his versatility. Shefali is effective in a small yet powerful role. Aditi is hardly there. Milind Gunaji is menacingly good. Veteran theatre artist Habib Tanvir seen onscreen after a long time is a treat to watch.

Direction: The showman for the first time changing his tracks from popular entertainers to serious meaningful cinema has outdone himself in all the departments. There are no popular Ghai touches visible in any frame yet he succeeds in delivering the desired impact. He deserves to be lauded for his courage and risk taking for attempting such a genre and not ending up making a dark and depressing film.

Script: One of the main USP of Black and White is its good story by Varon B K Sharma which has been worked out well by Ghai and his team into a multi layered screenplay. His penned dialogues are well worded as well. Amongst the most effective scenes in terms of writing and handling are the initial reels portions showing Afghanistan and its terror camps, Shefali's murder, Anil's subsequent break down and the climax confrontation between Anurag and Milind Gunaji. However, the romantic track between Aditi and Anurag, the songs woven around them could have totally been avoided as also a few sequences in the climax do bring the graph of the film down a bit. But nevertheless, Black and White does make for a good watch for connoisseurs of meaningful cinema.

- by Abhijeet Mhamunkar

 


Related Articles

Comments Post Comments
harrypablo   3/8/2008 4:20:54 PM
the best film to come so far this year, the suject should get the best story of the year award

Advertise with us on SBO & Indya.com
Untitled
STAR       |    Content Syndication    |    STAR in UK    |    STAR Select    |    Tata Sky
Copyright ©2000-2009 indya.com. All Rights Reserved.        Terms of Service   |  About us   |  Sitemap   |  Feedback